Classic Recordings Of Messiaen By Messiaen //

Album label: 
Release date: 
Recording date: 
Friday, January 1, 1943
Malcolm Ball
  • 1. Visions de l'Amen for 2 Pianos: Amen de la Creation (04:02)
  • 2. Visions de l'Amen for 2 Pianos: Amen des Etioles de la Planete a l'Anneua (05:20)
  • 3. Visions de l'Amen for 2 Pianos: Amen de l'Agonie de Jesus (06:30)
  • 4. Visions de l'Amen for 2 Pianos: Amen du Desir (09:54)
  • 5. Visions de l'Amen for 2 Pianos: Amed des Andes, des Saints, du Chant de Oiseaux (07:34)
  • 6. Visions de l'Amen for 2 Pianos: Amen de judgement (02:25)
  • 7. Visions de l'Amen for 2 Pianos: Amen de la Consummation (07:59)
  • 8. Quatre Etudes de Rythme: Ile de Feu 1 (01:57)
  • 9. Quatre Etudes de Rythme: Mode de valiurs et d'intensites (03:57)
  • 10. Quatre Etudes de Rythme: Neumes rythmiques (05:11)
  • 11. Quatre Etudes de Rythme: Ile de fue 2 (04:34)

Olivier Messiaen - piano
Yvonne Loriod - piano

Olivier MESSIAEN (1908-1992)
Historic Recordings:
Visions de l'Amen for two pianos (1943) [43.40]
Quatre Etudes de Rhythme (1951) [15.29]
Yvonne Loriod (piano) (1 Visions)
Olivier Messiaen (piano) (2 Visions and solo in Etudes)
rec. 1949 (Visions); 1951 (Etudes) ADD

Read more:
Compiled and edited by Malcolm Ball, this new CD is a major coup by FMR as it offers the only recording of Messiaen and Yvonne Loriod captures playing his pieces together. Conceived and produced by Malcolm Ball (the webmaster of the Messiaen website.....and self confessed Messiaen fanatic) he has persuaded the British Library to allow this music to be compiled onto CD with Malcolm using extremely sophisticated software to clean up the 78 records limited. The CD features Messiaens 'Visions de I'Amen' for 2 pianos and 'Quatre Etudes de Rythme' performed by Loriod and the composer, and this release makes a major contribution to this wonderful composers available repertoire on CD

"These recordings are assuredly for Messiaen devotees and for those drawn to the French avant-garde of the 1940s. The sound is taken down from 78s made available by the British Library with minimal processing and editing. For those in the know the sound bespeaks more of a Pearl approach than a Dutton or a Naxos.

Tholing some primitive and rough sound especially at the crumbly start of the Amen of Creationis the price of admission to an intense and turbulent performance. Do not expect perfection of ensemble either. Things are hectic and splashy at the start but improve as the work progresses. I am sure that in 1949 Loriod and the composer were still discovering the work they had premiered at the house of Mme Sivade in rue Blanche, Paris on 9 May 1943. Loriod had been the composer's extraordinary piano pupil since 1941. She takes the virtuosic decorative and birdsong segundo line while the composer takes the often profound and oratorical primo.

A couple of impressions: The Amen des anges, des saints du chant des Oiseauxsurprised me with its momentsof crystalline proto-jazz. After the explosions, dissonance and earthquakes of the earlier movements the hazed drift from sensual to religious ecstasy in Amen du désircreates its own closed and private world. The latter spans an impressively concentrated ten minutes. Its material and mood is closest to the luxurious sensuality of the Turangalilasymphony. The finale rushes onwards in a dazzle of bell sounds finding exaltation in the celebration.

The Etudes are untypical Messiaen in two ways. First they are not caught up in the religious-ecstatic experience and second they have a tendency to dry modernistic academicism which is at its most extreme in the two central studies. The Ile de Feumovements that open and close the work reflect the violent rites of Papua New Guinea and can be seen as one of the extremes of France's fascination with the exotics of the départements outre-mers. They are a far cry from the gentleness of Colin McPhee's Gamelan Anklungor the exultant simplicity of Britten'sPrince of the Pagodas. The Etudes were premiered on Radio Turin in 1951. This recording was made as part of a UNESCO project.

The case takes the form of a light cardfold with all the notes squeezed onto the card. The font is small; the notes extensive. They are by Malcolm Ball and are agreeably detailed. Full background on French and UK premieres is given together with biographical context and Messiaen's own commentary for the Visions.

Here are two works in authentic readings still having about them the brittle brilliance and rude intensity of creative discovery."
Rob Barnett